Document Type : Scientific-Research

Authors

1 Professor, Department of Social Sciences, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, Tehran University.

2 Professor, Department of Social Sciences, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz.

3 Associate Professor, Department of History, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz.

4 PhD Candidate in Sociology, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz.

Abstract

Domination mechanisms are product and producer of knowledge and historical narrations. Subalterns as objects of control and power exertion are represented but have not their own voice or own history. Subaltern history cannot be reconstructed through state archives and government documents, because these documents are selected to provide the mainstream narration. Existing representations hinder other possible ways of thought and alternative narrations. Thus, for a construction of subaltern narration, beyond existing representations, fragments and traces should be investigated. In Pahlavi I era, Iranian tribes faced suppression and compulsory settlement, but this violent suppression of further than a quarter of Iran population is not shown in nationalist histories and are summarized under security issues and they have silenced the issue. Urban nationalist elites and state ideology through representing Iran Tribes as source of insurgency, have legitimized their violent suppression. This study has selected the poems of a prisoner in Pahlavi I era, Agha 'Enayat Jvanroyi, as a fragment of these subalterns' history and using Hermeneutic method tries to criticize existing representations and reconstruct an alternative narration through this trace and fragment of subaltern voice.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Abrahamian, E. 1999. Īrāni Biyni Dū Inḳilāb. A. Gul Muḥammadī. & M.I. Fatāḥī. (Translators). Niy, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Aḥmadī, B. 2008. Risāliyih Tārīkhi, Djustārī dar Hirminūtīki Tārīkh. Markaz, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Amīr Aḥmadī, A. 1995. Khāṭirāti Nukhustīn Sipahbud dar Īrān. Pazhūhishgāhi wa Muṭāliʻāti Farhangī, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Amīr Ṭahmāsibī, ʻA. 2007. Yādāshthāī az Āshūbhāyi ʻAshāyirī wa Sīyāsīyi Āzarbāydjān. Shīrāzih, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
ʻAlawī, B. 1979. Pandjāh-o-Sinafar. Djāwīdān, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Arendt, H. 1973. The origins of Totalitarianism. New ed. with added prefaces. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York. (In English) (Book)
ʻAzīz Zādih, M.N. 2007. Riḍā Khān Pahlawī wa Sīyāsati Khalʻi Silāḥ wa Iskāni ʻAshāyirī Shāhsawan. The Temporary History of Iran, (37)10: 147-172. (In Persian with English Abstract) (Journal)
Bahār, M.T. 2009. Dīwāni Malik al-Shuʻarāʼ Bahār. Nigāh, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Bast, O. 2009. Disintegrating the ‘Discourse of Disintegration’. In Iran in the 20th century, by Touraj Atabaki. Tauris, London. (In English) (Book)
Bayāt, K. 1998. ʻAmalīyāti Luristān, Documents of Brigadier General (Sartīp) Shāh Bakhtī. Shīrāzih, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
-----. 2004. Riḍā Shāh wa ʻAshāyir. Djāmī, Tehran. (In Persian) (Parts of Book)
Chaturvedi, V. 2000. Mapping Subaltern Studies and the Postcolonial. Verso, London. (In English) (Book)
Cottom, R. 2018. Nsīyūnālīsm dar Īrān. 5th Ed. A.Tadayun. (Translator). Kawīr, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Cronin, S. 2007. Artish, Djāmiʻih wa Dūlat dar Īrān 1922-1924; dar Tadjadudi Āmirānih, Djāmiʻih wa Dūlat dar ʻAṣri Riḍā Shāh Tawasuṭi Tūradji Atābakī. P: 137-181.  M. Ḥaḳīḳat Khāh. (Translator). Ḳuḳnūs, Tehran. (In Persian) (Part of Book)
Cronin, S. 2008. Subalterns and Social Protest. Routledge, London. (In English) (Book)
Foran, J. 1999. Muḳāwimati Shikannandih; Tārīkhī Taḥawulāti Idjtimāʻīyi Īrān. A.Tadayun. (Translator). Rasā, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Gramsci, A. 2014. Notes on Italian History. In Selections from the Prison Notebooks of Antonio Gramsci, by Antonio Gramsci, Quintin Hoare and Geoffrey Nowell-Smith, 44–120. (Journal)
Guha, R. 1982. Subaltern Studies: Writing on South Asian History and Society. Oxford University Press, Delhi. (In English) (Book)
Hall, S. 1992. The West and the Rest: Discourse and power. In Formations of Modernity, by Stuart Hall and Bram Gieben. P. 275-331. Polity in Association with Open University, Oxford. (In English) (Book)
shimī, B. 2000. Dīwānī ʼĀghāʻīnāyih-ti. Abāṣāliḥ, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Herodotus. 2011. Tārīkhi Hirūdūt. M. Thāḳibfar. (Translator). Asāthīr, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Iggers, G. G. 2005. Historiography in the Twentieth Century. Wesleyan University Press, Middletown CT. (In English) (Book)
Itiḥādīih, M. 1983. Marām Nāmihā wa Niẓām Nāmihāyi Aḥzābi Sīyāsīyi Īrān dar Dūriyi Duwumi Madjlisi Shūrāyi Millī. Tārīkhi Īrān, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Kātūzīyān, M.ʻA. (Humāyūn). 1995. Iḳtiṣādi Sīyāsīyi Īrān az Mashrūṭīyat tā Pāyāni Silsiliyih Pahlawī. M.R. Nafīsī. & K. ʻAzīzī. (Translators). Markaz, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
------. 2002. Dūlat wa Djāmiʻih dar Īrān; Inḳirāḍi Ḳādjār wa Istiḳrāri Pahlawī. Ḥ. Afshār. (Translator). Markaz, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
------. 2007. Djāmiʻih wa Dūlat dar Dūriyi Riḍā Shāh; dar Tadjadudi Āmirānih, Djāmiʻih wa Dūlat dar ʻAṣri Riḍā Shāh Tawasuṭi Tūradji Atābakī. P: 23-64.  M. Ḥaḳīḳat Khāh. (Translator). Ḳuḳnūs, Tehran. (In Persian) (Part of Book)
Khāmiī, A. 1994. Khāṭirāti Sīyāsī. Guftār, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Law, J. and R. Benschop. 1997. Resisting Pictures: Representation, Distribution and Ontological Politics. In Ideas of Difference: Social Spaces and Labour of Division, by Kevin Hetherington and Rolland Munro. P.158-182. Blackwell Publishers, Oxford. (In English) (Part of Book)
Naṣīrī, M. ʻA. Bīgdilī. ʻA. ʻAlī Ṣūfī. R. Muʻīnī Rūdbālī. 2015. Pazhūhishī Darbāriyi Takhtih Ḳāpūyi Īlāt wa ʻAshāyiri Fārs dar ʻAṣri Pahlawīyi Awal wa Payāmadhāyi Mālīyātīyi Ān bā Itikā bi Asnādi Tārīkhī. Gandjīniyi Asnād, (94):6-27. (In Persian with English Abstract) (Journal)
Palmer, R.A. 2004. ʻIli Hirminūtīk, Naẓarīyiyih Taʼwīl dar Falsafihāyi Schleiermacher, Dilthey, Heidegger, Gadamer. 2nd Ed. M.S. Ḥanāī Kāshānī. (Translator). Hirmis, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Ricœur, P. 1984. Time and Narrative. Vol. 1. University of Chicago Press, Chicago. (In English) (Book)
Rūḥī, M. 2014. Problematize Kardani Gusasti Tārīkhīti Kurdistāni Īrān (Taʼamulī bar Shikāfi Pīshāmudirn / Mudirn). The Sociology of Iran, (4)14: 65-98. (In Persian with English Abstract) (Journal)
Said, E. 2008. Sharḳ Shināsī. L. Khandjī. (Translator). Amīr Kabīr, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Šesnić, J. 2007. From Shadow to Presence. Vol. 1. Rodopi, Amsterdam; New York. (In English) (Book)
Sulṭānī, M.Ṭ. 2006. Khāṭirāti Sulṭānī; az Ḳaṣri Shīrīn tā Ḳaṣri Ḳadjar. Suhā, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)
Tapper, R. 2004. Nimūniyi Īli Shāhsawan. Djāmī, Tehran. (In Persian) (Parts of Book)
The National Documents Organization. 1933-1939. Parwandiyih Kiyfarī Yikī az Akrād Bināmi Muḥammad Ṭāhir Biyg Mutaham bi Shirārat.  No, 47/294. (Document)
------. 1933-1940. Parwandiyih Kiyfarī Yikī az Akrādi Marīwān Bināmi Amīn. No, 32/294. (Document)
------. 1933-1942. Parwandiyih Kiyfarī Muḥammad ʻAlī Biyg az Ṭāyifiyi Bahrām Biygīyi Marīwān. No, 32/294. (Document)
Young, R. 2012. Usṭūriyih Sifīd: Gharb wa Niwishtani Tārīkh. Dj. Karīmī. & K. Khāliḳ Panāh. (Translators). Institute for Social and Cultural Studies, Tehran.  (In Persian) (Book)
Wāʻiẓ, N. 2010. Ahdāf wa Rawandi Sīyāsati Farhangīyi Dūlati Pahlawīyi Awal Barāyi Īlāt wa ʻAshāyir. The History of Islam & Iran, 19(1): 135-163. (In Persian with English Abstract) (Journal)
------. 2010. Nahādhā wa Shīwihāyi Khaṭi Mashy Gudhārī dar Dūlati Pahlawīyi Awal. Pazhūhishhāyi Tārīkhī, (4): 109-130. (In Persian with English Abstract) (Journal)