Akhbārīsm and Anti-rational Theme: Re-Considering a Misconception

Hoseinzadeh Yazdi, Mahdi; Vatankhah, Koosha

doi:10.22051/hii.2022.36541.2488

Document Type : Scientific-Research

Authors

¹ Assistant Professor and Faculty Member to the Department of Islamic Social Sciences, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

² PhD in Social Thought of Muslim Thinkers, Department of Islamic Social Sciences, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22051/hii.2022.36541.2488

Abstract

Akhbārīsm as a jurisprudential school within Imami scholarship came into existence in the 11thAH/17thAD century and caused many long-standing changes in the history of Imami ijtihad. Accordingly, the majority of research projects into Iran’s history include a chapter concerned with the Usūli-Akhbārī conflict. Akhbari studies is a field wherein many researchers from various academic backgrounds have contributions who, despite differences in perspectives and projects, share some themes amongst which anti-rationality is the most important and the most re-producing one.
A group of researchers treat Akhbārīs as opponents not only to usūl al-fiqh but also philosophy, theology, and theoretical mysticism and at a higher level to every genre of argumentation and reasoning while in some cases they step forward to basically opposing thinking of any kind. A group of researchers attribute some essentialities to the school and put it in the same line with sedentary style of thinking while others suggest that Akhbārī thought was good enough to suppress popular movements. A group of researchers compare this school, in epistemology and methodology, with Salafism, Scripturalism, and Literalism. Anti-rational theme is extensively repeated across different research projects to the extent that it has now become a cliché preventing researchers from a descent observation. In this way the constructive role of the Akhbārī thought and the necessary function performed by Akhbārī ulama in the history of Shi’ite jurisprudence is being neglected.
Putting anti-rational theme at the centre of the study and in order to open up a new horizon for Akhbārī literature, this paper is devoted to an evaluation of the works of eight scholars who actively took part in the formation of Akhbārī literature. In doing so, the article attempts to challenge the existing style of interpretation dominant over studies concerned with Akhbārīsm.

Keywords

20.1001.1.2008885.1401.32.53.4.8

Main Subjects

History of Islamic Iran

References

List of sources with English handwriting

Abisaab, R. J. (2017). Converting Persian: Religion and Power in the Safavid Empire. Translated by M. Sefatgol. 2^ed Edition. Tehran: Publications of Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought (in Persian)

Al-e-Ghafour, M. (2005). Ulama and Their Political Positions in Akhbari/Usuli Schools, 1^st Edition, Qom: Bustan Ketab Publishing (In Persian)

Ameri Shahrabi, M. (2016). Amin Astarabadi and the Role of Reason in Understanding Religion: Critiques from a Sadraean Perspective. MA Dissertation. Shahed University. Tehran. Iran (in Persian)

Ansari, H. (2016). Life and Work of An Imami Muhadith in Early 13th Century A.H. Tehran: Māhī Publications (In Persian)

Ansari, H. (2016). From Imami Narrators to Akhbari Ulama: A Look at Changes in Imami Jurisprudence. Tehran: Māhī Publications (In Persian)

Astarabādī, M. A. (2016). Dāneshnāmeye Shāhī. M. Hajian & A. A. Zalpour (ed.). Tehran: Hekmat & Andisheh Publishing Co. (In Persian)

Astarabādī, M. A. (2005). al-Fawā’īd al-Madanīyya. with Nūr al-DDīn al-Mūsawī al-‘Āmilī’s al-Shawāhid al-Makkiyya in the footnotes, Qom: Nashr-e- Islāmī Institution (in Arabic)

Bayat, M. (1989). ‘The Usuli-Akhbari Controversy’, in S. H. Nasr, S. V. R. Nasr, and H. Dabashi (ed.): Expectation of the Millennium: Shi’ism in History, New York: University of New York Press, pp. 281-283

Ebrahimi Dinani, Gh. (2013). The Adventure of Philosophical Thought in Muslim World. Vol. I, 6th Edition, Tehran: Ṭarh-e- No Publications (in Persian)

Enayat, H. (1989). ‘The Debates Over the Constitutional Revolution’ in: S. H. Nasr, S. V. R. Nasr, H. Dabashi (ed.): Expectation of the Millennium: Shi’ism in History, New York: State University of New York Press, pp. 311-330

Flick, U. (2009). An Introduction to Qualitative Research. Translated by H. Jalili. 2ed Edition. Tehran: Ney Publishing House (in Persian)

Hajian, M & Zalpour, A.A. (2016). Akhbārīsm and the Reason: Rejection or Consilience?. Prologue to Dāneshnāmeyi Shāhī. Tehran: Hekmat & Andisheh Publishing Co. (In Persian)

Hoseinzadeh Yazdi, M. & Vatankhah K. (2022). Sociological Insights into Secularist Reading of Akhbarism: A Critical Consideration. Quarterly of Social Studies Research in Iran, Vol. 10, No. 4: 1237-1260 (in Persian)

Jafarian, R. (1991). Religion and Politics under Safavids. Qom: Ansarian Publications (In Persian)

Jahangiri, M. (2009). Akhbarism and Iǰtīhād. Mashhad: Sabrā Publications (In Persian)

Julien, H. (2008). Content Analysis. in L. M. Given (ed.): The Sage Encyclopedia of Qualitative Research Methods, Volumes 1&2, New York: Sage Publications Inc., pp. 120-121

Kakae, Q. (1996). An Introduction to Shiraz Philosophical School: Sadr al-Din Dashtaki. Quarterly of Kheradname-ye Sadra, No. 3: 82-89 (in Persian)

Kakae, Q. (1996). An Introduction to Shiraz Philosophical School: Ghyath al-Din Mansur Dashtaki. Quarterly of Kheradname-ye Sadra, No. 7: 59-67 (in Persian)

Lockyer, Sh. (2008). Textual Analysis. in L. M. Given (ed.): The Sage Encyclopedia of Qualitative Research Methods, Volumes 1&2, New York: Sage Publications Inc, pp. 865-866

Modarresi, H. (1984). Rationalism and Traditionalism in Shi’i Jurisprudence: A Preliminary Survey. Studia Islamica, No. 59, pp. 141-158

Modarresi, H. (1989). An Introduction to Shi'i Law, Translated by M.A. Fikrat, 1st Edition, Mashhad: Astān-e- Quds Radavi Publications (in Persian)

Movahid, S. M (2012). Amin Astarabadi and Søren Kierkegaard on Religion and Reason. MA Dissertation. Baqir al-Olum University. Qom. Iran (in Persian)

Qorbani Sini, M. (2012). Amin Astarabadi and the Function of Reason in Religion. MA Dissertation. University of Qom. Iran (in Persian)

Quivy, R. & Campenhoudt L. V. (2006). Manual for Research in the Social Sciences. Translated by A. Nikgohar. 2^ed Edition, Tehran: Tootia Publications (in Persian)

Rajabi, M. H. (2008). Rise of Akhbārīsm under Safavids: Context and Causes. Doctoral Thesis. University of Tehran. Iran (in Persian)

Radi, A. (2007). Traditionalists (Akhbarian) And Their Role in Shiite History. Journal of ANDISHE-E-NOVIN-E-DINI. Vol. 3. No. 8: 107 -131 (in Persian)

Saboorian, M. & Parsania H. (2018). An Analysis on the Rise and Decline of the Akhbaris. Quarterly of History of Islam and Iran. Vol. 28. No. 128: 89-112 (in Persian)

Saroukhani, B. (2005). Research Methods in Social Sciences. Vol. I, 10^th Edition. Tehran: Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies (In Persian)

Sharifi, A.H (2004). Akhbari Ulama and their Attitudes Towards Reason. A Quarterly for Shia Studies, Vol. 2. Issue. 6: 23-57 (in Persian)

Sefatgol, M. (2003). Safavid Administration of Avqaf: Structure, Changes, and Functions (1077-1135/ 1666-1722) in: A. J. Newman (ed.): Society and Culture in the Early Modern Middle East: Studies on Iran in the Safavid Period. Leiden: Brill

Sefatgol, M. (2002), The Structure of Religious Thought and Institution in Safavid Persia: A History of Religious Changes in Iran (10^th -12^th AH Centuries), Tehran: Rasā Institute of Cultural Services (in Persian)

Akhbārīsm and Anti-rational Theme: Re-Considering a Misconception

References

References

Volume 32, Issue 53 - Serial Number 143Spring 2022April 2022Pages 79-100

Volume 32, Issue 53 - Serial Number 143
Spring 2022
April 2022
Pages 79-100