Document Type : Scientific-Research
Authors
1 PhD student in Public Administration, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Public Administration, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
3 Associate Professor of History, Department of Najaf Abad, Islamic Azad University, Najaf Abad, Iran
Abstract
The present study aims to develop a model for public administration. The authors try to use the science of history to provide this opportunity to decision-makers, policymakers, and government managers that they can use to carefully examine a model of governance.
One of the best models in this regard is the governance of Amirkabir. In this study, following the conceptual framework approach and using the documentary research method, focusing on studying and reviewing primary sources and texts, essential data in historical sources have been extracted. While reviewing in the form of an exploratory and inductive plan, we presented a relatively clear picture of the governance of Amirkabir. The proposed conceptual framework of this research consists of 189 concepts organized in the form of 23 categories, 12 themes, and six dimensions. The extracted concepts are also categorized. A number of the concepts are placed in a category, and the related categories locate in a theme, and the related themes form dimension.
The identified dimensions are political measures, cultural measures, bureaucratic measures, protection measures, economic measures, and social measures obtained with the cooperation of the Association of Experts. The framework provides a basis for understanding the various aspects of Amirkabir governance and finally provides a conceptual model of this politician's actions that can be a reference for managers and policymakers in public administration in Iran.
This study shows that historical data can be used to define new concepts and new components in public administration.
Keywords
Main Subjects
List of sources with English handwriting
- Adamīāt, Fereydūn (1389 Š.), Amīr Kabīr va Īrān, Tehran: ḵārazmī. [In Persian]
- Adamīāt, Fereydūn (1356 Š.), Andīša-ye Taraqī va Ḥokūmat-e Qānūn (‘Aṣr-e Sipahsālār), Tehran: Soḵan. [In Persian]
- Aḥmadvand, Šojā’; Somaya Ḥamīdī (1392 Š.), “Čahār Rivāyat dar Fahm-e Ma‘nā-ye Moṭāliāt-e Mīānrištaīī”, Faṣlnāma-ye v dar ‘Olūm-e Ensānī, 6, No. 2, pp. 31-53. [In Persian]
- Aḥmadzāda, Moḥamad Amīr (1391 Š.), “Bistarhā-ye Taḥdīd va Tosi‘a-ye amnīat dar Īrān-e ‘Aṣr-e Qāĵār ba Takīd bar Āsībšināsī-ye Nahādhā-ye Amnīatsāz”, Moṭāliāt-e Tārīḵ-e Entiẓāmī, No. 1, pp. 45-74. [In Persian]
- Akbarī, Moḥammad ‘Alī (1393 Š.), Čālišhā-ye ‘Aṣr-e Moder dar Īrān-e ‘Ahd-e Qāĵār, Tehran: Našr-e Tārīḵ-e īrān. [In Persian]
- Alvānī, Mahdī (1369 Š.), Modīrīat-e ‘Omūmī, Tehran: Našr-e Nai. [In Persian]
- Aṭharī, Ḥossein (1393 Š.), “Taḥlīl-e Goftimānī-e Eṣlāḥāt-e Amīr Kabīr dar Motūn-e Montaḵab-e Rūznāma-ye Vaqāya Etifāqīa”, Peĵūhināma-ye ‘Olūm-e Sīāsī, 8, N. 3, pp. 69-98. [In Persian]
- Āl Dāvūd, Sayyid ‘Alī, (ed.) (1371 Š.), Nāmihā-ye Amīr Kabīr bi Enżimām-e Navādir al-Amīr, Tehran: Našr-e Tārīḵ-e Īrān. [In Persian]
- ‘Alīzāda Bīrĵandī, Zahrā; Somaya Ḥamīdī, Elhām Malikzāda (1396 Š.), “Vākāvī-e ḵāstgāh va Kārkard-e Nišānhā-ye Dolatī-e ‘Aṣr-e Qāĵār”, Maĵala-ye Ĵostārhā-ye Tārīḵī, 8, No. 1, pp. 79-98. [In Persian]
- ‘Aṭār, Sa‘īd; ‘Alī Ḵāja Nāīnī (1394 Š.), “Barrasī va Taḥlīl-e ‘AvAmil-e Moaṯir bar Nākārāmadī-e Niẓām-e Sīāsī dar Īrān”, Faṣlnāma-ye Sīāsatgoẕārī ‘Omūmī, 1, No, 1, pp. 1-20. [In Persian]
- Bašīrīa, Ḥossein (1380 Š.), Mavāna Tosi‘a Sīāsī dar Īrān, Tehran: Gām-e No. [In Persian]
- Diḥqān, Manūčihr (1348 Š.), “Niẓām-e Nāṣirī”, Maĵala-ye Barrisīhā-ye Tārīḵī, 4, No. 4, pp. 147-150. [In Persian]
- Eĵlālī, Farzām (1371 Š.), Bonyān-e Ḥokūmat-e Qāĵār, Tehran: Našr-e Nai.
- Etimād al-Salṭana, Moḥammad Ḥasan ḵān (1349 Š.), Ṣadr al-Tavārīḵ, edited by Moḥammad Mošīrī, Tehran: Entišārāt-e Vaḥid. [In Persian]
- Etimād al-Salṭana, Moḥammad Ḥasan ḵān (1367 Š.), Mirāt al-Boldān, edited by Abdulḥossein Navāīī, Mīr Ḥāšim Moḥadiṯ, Vol. 2, Tehran: Dānišgāh-e Tihrān. [In Persian]
- Eqbāl Āštīānī, ‘Abbās (1361 Š.), Mīrzā Taqī ḵān Amīr Kabīr, edited by ĪraAfšār, Tehran: Ḵārazmī. [In Persian]
- Estiqlāl, Ḥossein (1352 Š.), Čihil Sāl Dādgostarī dar Šīrāz, Šīrāz: Čāpḵāna- Mūsā. [In Persian]
- Emāmī, Sayyid Moĵtabā; Moḥammad Ẕolfaqārzāda; Ḥossein ĵaṣāf Momfarid (1391 Š.), “Āmūziš-e Mīānrištaīī-e Modīrīat-e Dolatī dar īrān, Elzāmāt-e Barnāmarīzī-ye Darsī”, Faṣlnāma-ye Moṣāliāt-e Mīānrštaīī dar ‘Olūm-e Ensānī, No. 16, pp. 107-143. [In Persian]
- Floof, Willem (1366 Š.), Ĵostārhāīī az Tārīḵ-e Eĵtimā‘ī Īrān dar ‘Aṣr-e Qājār, translated by Abulqāsim Sirrī, Tehran: Tūs. [In Persian]
- Ḥaĵārīān, Sa‘īd (1390/10/24 Š.), “Amīr Niẓām yā ‘Azīz Solṣān”, Rūznama-ye Šarq, No. 1441. [In Persian]
- Ḥāĵī Yūsefī, Amīr Moḥammad; Moḥammd Moḥammadīān (1397 Š.), “Manābi ‘e Qodrat-e Eĵtimā’ī, Sāḵtār-e Dolat va Ravābi-te ḵāriĵi-e Qāĵār”, Dāniš-e Sīāsī, 4, No. 1, pp. 90-116. [In Persian]
- Hāšimīān, Aḥmad (īraĵ) (1379 s.), Taḥavvolāt-e Farhangī-e īrān dar Dora-ye Qāĵārīya va Madrasa-ye Dār al-Fonūn, Tehran: Moasisa-ye Ĵoḡrāfīāīī va Kārtogirāfī. [In Persian]
Ḥidāyat, Reżā Qolī ḵān (1339 Š.), Tārīḵ-e Rożat al-Ṣafā-ye Nāṣirī, Tehran: Kitābfoūši-e ḵayyām. [In Persian]
- Homāyūn, Moḵbir (1340 Š.), “Amīr Kabīr va Raviš-e Ĵadīd-e Sarbāzgīrī dar Īrān”, Maĵala-ye Armaḡān, 30, No. 1, pp. 132-133. [In Persian]
- Ĵafarī, ‘Alī; Mortażā Dihqānnižād, Fereidūn Allāhyārī (1395 Š.), “Eṣlāḥ-e Niẓām-e Edārī-e īrān dar ‘Aṣr-e Qā bā Takīd bar Qānūn-e Estiḵdām-e Kišvarī”, Maĵala-ye Tārīḵ-e Eslām va Īrān, No. 29, pp. 5-38. [In Persian]
- Kaĵbāf, ‘Alī Akbar; Kūroš Hādīān (1390 Š.), “Olgū-ye Modīrīat-e Boḥrān dar Dora-ye Qāĵār bā Takīd bar Narš-e Dolatmardān-e Kord dar Modīrīat-e Boḥrān-e Sālar”, Maĵala-ye Moṭāliāt-e Tārīḵ-e Eslām, 3, Np. 10, pp. 115-143. [In Persian]
- Kāva Ĵibilī, ‘Alīreżā (1371 Š.), Sīāsat-e ḵāriĵī-e Amīr Kabīr, Tehran: Našr-e Ĵūyā. [In Persian]
- Makkī, Ḥossein (1366 Š.), Zindigānī-e Mīrzā Taqī ḵān Amīr Kabīr, Tehran: Našr-e Tārīḵ-e Īrān. [In Persian]
- Moḥammadī Āīīn, Šahrzād (1396 š.), “Barrasī va Taḥlīl-e Eṣlāḥāt-e Amīr Kabīr Az Dīdgh-e Sayāḥān va Kārgozārān-e ḵāriĵī 1807-1852”, Pārsa, No. 28, pp. 97-114. [In Persian]
- Moḥammad ḵān, Bahādor (1313 Š.), “Yik Šaḵs-e Mohim yā Mīrzā Taqī ḵān Atābak”, Maĵala-ye Armaḡān, No. 15, pp. 208-217. [In Persian]
- Mortażāīīfard, Maḥmūd; ‘Alī Bīgdelī; ‘Alīreżā ‘Alīṣūfī (1397 Š.), “Taḥavolāt-e Eṣlāḥāt-e Qażāīī dar Doray-e Amīr Kabīr va Sipahsālār”, Maĵala-ye Peĵūhīš-e Ḥoqūq-e ‘Omūmī, No. 59, pp. 189- 215. [In Persian]
- Mostofī, ‘Abdullāh (1341 Š.), Šarḥ-e Zindigānī-e Man, Vol. 1, 2, Tehran: Zavvār. [In Persian]
- Mūsavī, Āraš (1387 Š.), “Tosa ‘a-ye Tārīḵī va Mabānī-e Ma‘rifatšināsī-e Ravānšināsī-e ‘Elm”, Raviššināsī-e ‘Olūm-e Ensānī, 14, No. 55, pp. 95-111. [In Persian]
- Nargisīān, ‘Abbās (1378 Š.), “Nigāḥī bi Sair-e Taṭavor-e Modīrīat-e Dolat”, Farhang-e Modīrīat, 4, No. 17, pp. 157-195. [In Persian]
- Parnīānī, Mīlād (1393 Š.), “Tafsīr-e Eṣlāḥāt-e Nākām bā Ĵāma‘ašināsī-e Noḵbakošī dar īrān bā Takid bar Amīr Kabīr”, ḵiradnāma, No. 12, pp. 28-45. [In Persian]
- Pīrnīā, Ḥasan; Abbās Eqbāl (1381 Š.), Tārīḵ-e Īrān, Tehran: Moasisa-ye Emtišārāt-e Nigāh. [In Persian]
- Polak, Jakob Edward (1865), Persien: Das Land und Seine Bewohner: Ethnographische Schilderungen, Leigzig: Brockhaus. [In Persian]
- Qāimmaqāmī, Ĵaḥangīr (1346 Š.), “Varaqī az Tārīḵ-e Artiš-e Īrān: Tārīḵča-ye Sarbāzgīrī dar īrān”, Maĵala-ye Barrasīhā-ye Tārīḵī, 2, N. 2, pp. 40-49. [In Persian]
- Qāzvīnī, Moḥammad Šafī‘(1370 Š.), Qānūn-e Qazvīnī, edited by īraĵ Afšār, Tehran: Ṭalāya. [In Persian]
- Rāīīn, Esmā‘īl (1362 Š.), Ḥoqūqbegīrān-e Engilīs dar Īrān, Tehran: Entišārāt-e Ĵāvīd. [In Persian]
- Raḥmānī, Tūraĵ (1391 Š.), “Darāmadī bar Ta ‘āmol-e Tārīḵ va Sīāsat; bi Sūye Dānišī Binārištaīī”, Faṣlnāma-ye Moṭāliāt-e MīānrīštaII dar ‘Olūm-e Ensānī, No. 3, pp. 53-75. [In Persian]
- Reżāīān, ‘Alī (1387 Š.), Mabānī-e Sāzmān va Modīrīat, Tehran: SAmt.
- Rinānī, Moḥsin (1396 š.), “Nātavānī dar Goftigū, az Amīr Kabīr tā Šeiḵ Šoĵā ‘, available in: www.renani.net. [In Persian]
- Sārlī Arāzlī (1373 Š.), Tārīḵ-e Torkamanistān, Tehran: Vizārat-e Omūr-e ḵāriĵa. [In Persian]
- Sā ‘ādat, Ebrāhīm (1370 Š.), Tārīḵ-e Pīšrafthā-ye Piziškī dat Haftād Sāl-e Aḵīr 1300 ta 1370, Tehran. [In Persian]
- Sipihr (Lisān al-Molk), Moḥammad Taqī (1385 Š.), Nāsiḵ al-Tavārīḵ, Vol. 3, Tehran: Eslāmīa. [In Persian]
- Ša‘bānī, Reżā; Farībā Ṣan ‘atī (1395 Š.), “Mīrzā Āqā ḵān Nūrī va Mordarīg-e Eṣlāḥāt-e Amīr Kabīr”, Taḥqīqāt-e Tārīḵ-e Eĵtimāīī, 6, No. 1, pp. 208-228. [In Persian]
- Šāhābādī, Moḥammad Mahdī; ‘Alī Aṣḡar Pūr‘ezzat; Ḥasan Dānāīīfard; Raḥmatallāh Qolīpūr (1393 Š.), “Taḥlīlī bar Rūykard-e Tārīḵī bi Tosi ‘a-ye Sistem-e ḵaṭmašigoẕārī-e ‘Omūmī, Mabānī-e Naẓarī va Oslūb-e Eĵrā”, Faṣlnāma-ye Raviššināsī-e ‘Olūm-e Ensānī, 20, No. 81, pp. 73-110. [In Persian]
- Šahrāmnīā, Amīr Mas‘ūd; Maīd Eskandarī (1389 Š.), “’Elal-e Nākāmī-e Noḵbigān-e ‘Aṣr-e Qāĵār dar ravand-e Tosi ‘ayāftigī-e Īrān”, Rāhbord-e Yās, pp. 312-331. [In Persian]
- Timūrī, Ebrāhīm (1332 Š.), ‘Aṣr-e Bīḵabarī yā Tārīḵ-e Emtīāzāt dar Īrān, Širat-e Ḥāĵ Moḥammad Ḥosssein Eqbāl va Šorakā. [In Persian]
- Tonkābonī, Ḥamīd (1389 Š.), “Manzilat-e Qānūn va Naẓm dar Naẓarīahā-ye ‘Olūm-e Eĵtimā’ī va Modīrīāt’ Pīšina-ye Ān dar Edāra-ye Īrān-e ‘Aṣr-e Qāĵār, Ĵāma‘e Peĵūhī Farhangī, 1, No. 2, pp. 35-66. [In Persian]
- Valade, Bernard (1387 Š.), Możū ‘e Mīānrištagī, translated by Toḥīda Mollābāšī, Tehran: Peĵūhiškada-ye Moṭālīāt-e Farhangī va Eĵtimāīī.
- Varĵāvand, Parvīz (1372 Š.), “Yikṣad va Panĵāhomīn Sāl-e Ṣadr-e A ‘ẓamī-e Amīr Kabīr”, Māhnāma-ye Farhangī Honarī-e Kilk, No. 43-44, pp. 112-118.
- Yiktāīī, Maĵīd (1352 Š.), “Mālīyya-e Kišvar dar Zamān-e Qāĵār”, Maĵala-ye Barrasīhā-ye Tārīḵī, 8, No. 49, pp. 139-176. [In Persian]
- Zāhidī, ams al-Sādat; Ḥamīd Tonkābonī (1388 Š.), “Darāmadī bar Rīšašināsī-e Nahād-e Dīvānsālārī-e īrān dar Dora-ye Avval-e Qājār”, Maĵala-ye Farhang, No. 71, pp. 109-146. [In Persian]
- Zībākalām, Ṣādiq (1379 Š.), “Ḥākimīat-e Qāĵārhā, Amīr Kabīr va Eṣlāḥāt”, Maĵala-ye Dāniškada-ye hoqūq va ‘Olūm-e Sīāsī, No. 50, pp. 202-223. [In Persian]
References in English, French and German
- Algar, H. (accessed on 30 December 2012), “AMĪR KABĪR, MĪRZĀ TAQĪ KHAN”, Encyclopædia Iranica, I/9, pp.959-963. Available online at http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/amir-e-kabir-mirza-taqi-khan.
- Algar, Hamid (1969), Religion and State in Iran, 1785-1906, Berkeley, Los Angeles: University of California.
- Amanat, Abbas (1997), Pivot of the Universe: Nasir Al-Din Shah Qajar and the Iranian Monarchy 1831-1896, Tauris.
- Arasteh, Reza (1962), Education and Social Awakening in Iran, Leide.
- Basarab, Nicolescu; Lima de Freita et Edgar Morin (n. d.), «La transdisciplinarité–Manifeste», Éditions du Rocher Collection Transdisciplinarité, Monaco.
- Beddie, Francesca (2010), "Repackaging History for Policy Purposes", National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER).
- Binder, Leonard (1962), Iran Political in A Changing Society, Berkeley.
- Brugsch, Heinrich Karl (2012), Reise der K. Preussischen Gesandtschaft nach Persien: 1860 und 1861, Ulan Press.
- Carr, Edward Hallet (1964), What is History?, Knopf.
- Curzon, George Nathaniel (1966), Persia and Persia Question, London: Frank Cass and Co.
- Denhardt, R. B. (1984), Theories of Public Administration, Pacific Grove, California: Brooks/Cole Publishing Co.
- Effland, Anne (2012), “Synergies of Past and Present: The Mutual Benefits of Policy History and Policy Analysis”, Agricultural History, Vol.86, No.4, pp.192-205.
- Entner, Marvin L. (1965), Russo-Persian Commercial Relations, 1828-1914, Gaines Ville: University of Florida Press.
- Gobineau, Joseph Arthur (1905), Trois ans en Asie, de 1855 a 1858, Paris: E. leroux.
- Grattan, Robert (2008), “Crafting management history”, journal of management History, Vol.14, Issue.2, pp.174-18.
- Issawi, Charles Philip (1966), The Economic history of Iran, 1800-1914, London: University of Chicago Press.
- Lorentz, John (1971), Iran’s Great Reformers of the Nineteenth Century: an Analysis of Amir Kabir’s Reforms, Iranian Studies, Vol. 4, Issue 2-3, pp. 85-103.
- Newell, TW.H (2001), “A Theory of Interdisciplinary studies”, Issues in integrative studies, No.19, pp. 1-25.
- Pierson, Paul (2005), “The Study of policy Development”, journal of policy History, Vol.17, Issue. 01, pp. 5-34.
- Philips, David (2014), “Comparatography, History and policy quotation: some reflections”, Comparative education, 50:1, pp.73-83.
- Postnote (2009), “Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology”, LESSONS FROM HISTORY, Vol. 323, pp 1-4.
- Reuss, Martin (1988), “The Myth and Reality of Policy History: A Response to Robert Kelleyn”, The Public Historian, Vol.10, No.1,pp. 41-49.
- Scott. J.(2006), A Matter of Record: Documentary Sources in Social Research, combridge: polity.
- Sheil, Mary Leonora (1856), Glimpses of Life and Manners in Persia, New York: Arno Press.
- Stanford, Michael (1994), A Companion to the Study of History, Wiley-Blackwell.
- Sykes, Percy Molesworth (1915), A History of Paris, London: Macmillan and Co.
- Katouzian, Mohammad Ali (1992), The Political Economy of Modern Iran: Despotism and Pseudo-Modernism, 1926-1979, Houndmills: Macmillan.
- Lambton, Ann Katharine Swyford (1956), “Quis custodiet custodes: Some Reflections on the Persian Theory of Government”, Studia Islamica, No. 5, pp. 125-148.
- McCullagh, Behan (2004), The Logic of History, Putting Postmodernism in Perspective, Routledge.
- Waldo, D. (1975), “Education for Public Administration in Seventies”, in American Public Administration: past, present, and future, Mosher F.C. (Ed), University of Alabama Press.
- Watson, Robert Grant (1866), A History of Persia: from the Beginning og the Nineteenth Century to the Year 1858, London: Smith Elder.
- Yeselson, Abraham (1959), United States-Persian Diplomatic Relations 1883-1921, New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
)